Snow or Treadmill?

Chicago is currently in a [record] 290 day stretch of no snow but that is about to end today. Starting this afternoon, we have a winter storm warning issued until early tomorrow morning. We are expected to have high winds, ice, and snow [although not as much as other states in the Midwest!]. I’m not a big fan of snow, unless it comes on Christmas Eve and leaves the day after Christmas, but I know a lot of people have been waiting for snow for quite a while.

While I’m definitely an outdoor runner, once my early morning runs are full of snow and ice, I start to debate whether or not it would be safer for me to spend my mornings at my gym on a treadmill.

Generally, I run outside if it’s over 15 degrees (I also consider the windchill), not icy, and we’re not experiencing a blizzard (I did this once and it was miserable). On the weekends, I try to run later in the morning to allow people time to shovel the sidewalks and plow the streets. I also tend to run through the city more and less on the lakeshore path because the city sidewalks are more likely to be clear. Most importantly, I adjust my expectations given the weather. If it’s not too icy but there is lots of snow, I’ll head out running with a goal of getting in the mileage at whatever pace is feasible. There’s no need to get frustrated over speed when it’s completely outside of your control.

Deciding whether to run on the treadmill or brave the outdoors can be a tough call and while slipping on the icy lakeshore path is not fun, neither is becoming injured from running and striding differently on a treadmill.

So what do you do when it starts to get snowy? Run on the treadmill or run outdoors?

43 thoughts on “Snow or Treadmill?

  1. well, as you can read in my post today, i am super lazy in general about running inside so i typically stick with the treadmill, but i actually like running when it’s cold outside. i’m super pumped for some christmas break runs in the cold weather – packing all my cold gear! make sure you get that snow out of chicago’s system by tomorrow okay? i don’t want my flight delayed or cancelled!
    molly @ heart, sole & cereal recently posted..thankful thursday: bad photo editionMy Profile

  2. In winter, I normally TM during the week due to dark and/or ice (except Weds I meet a group so we usually run all weather.) I run outside most weekends even w/ice/snow (and yaktrax!) I use below 10 F and/or very cold wind chill as the cut off. I may be the only one but I like watching the Today show and doing TM intervals!

    • Sometimes running on the treadmill is a nice excuse to catch up on news, I did that this morning and my run was short enough to be enjoyable :) . How do you like the yaktrax? I’ve thought about buying them didn’t because I thought it would feel weird to run in them!

  3. Honestly, I don’t run at all when it snows! I don’t have a gym membership, so running outside is my only option. Instead I do a lot of Fitnessista’s video workouts…and watch Sex and the City. :)

  4. This actually will probably be the first time that I’ve ever had to deal with winter weather. Last winter was the first winter where I was a runner, and since last winter was pretty much nonexistent, it didn’t affect my outdoor running at all (and I was still healing up from a back injury, so almost all of my cardio from January to mid-February was in the pool or on a bike. I only ran once every other week during that stretch). 15 degrees sounds like a good cutoff, though…I’ll have to keep that in mind if we actually get a real winter this winter!
    Bethany @ Accidental Intentions recently posted..Thursday ThingsMy Profile

    • Yeah, I slipped and hit my head while running and ended up with a concussion two years ago. I’m much more careful now. Funny how injuries change things :P .

  5. When I lived in Forest Park I would just run in the street since there wasn’t much traffic and they kept them pretty clear. I once tried to run on a forest preserve path since sometimes the snow gets compacted by the cross-country skiers but that did not go so well. Basically, though, unless it’s super-duper icy I plan to run outside.
    Erin recently posted..Why the Chicago Running Community is the BestMy Profile

    • I can imagine the forest preserve path being a difficult run but I give you so much credit for trying. I’m sure it was so pretty!

  6. This is what I’ve been wondering about, since this is my first winter running! I have two runs scheduled this weekend, and I’m really worried they’ll have to be on a treadmill because of the snow. But people in my neighborhood are kind of bad about clearing the sidewalks – I’ve wiped out more than a few times just walking to the train – so I worry about running around here. It’s really interesting and helpful to read everyone’s thoughts on this!
    Anne recently posted..Outfit Post: Date NightMy Profile

  7. If I can run safely outside, that’s my preference. I will run if it’s a little bit icy out (if it’s possible to run around the ice patches), I will run after a snowfall, usually sticking to side streets after the snow plows have gone through. If the sidewalks aren’t too bad, I will run while it is snowing out, as long as it’s not coming down too heavy. I’ll deal with the cold down to single digits. But somedays I just have no motivation … so I’ll just move my run to the next day if possible. I haven’t been on a treadmill in over a year. I’d like to keep it that way :)
    Maggie recently posted..Recipe: Delicious CornbreadMy Profile

  8. Running in the snow/cold definitely intimidates me…it’s so hard to actually get out the door! I think I’m one of the few people who actually doesn’t mind the treadmill. I’ve been loving doing short, speedwork runs. It’s working better for me now since I’m not training for anything…but I can see how a long run could get incredibly boring.
    Megan @ runnningonjava recently posted..I’m home!!!My Profile

    • I ran 16 miles on the treadmill once, it was torture! But you’re right for shorter runs it can be nice to just tough it out and not have to go outside :) .

  9. I have a feeling I will be doing a lot of treadmill runs this winter. In the past I have usually just quit running during the winter when it got to cold/icy/snowy to run outside. I am a little more tolerable of the treadmill now but it has to have a personal TV.
    When I am in Iowa I will just run on the road because they seem to be less slick than the sidewalks usually.
    Alyssa @ Don’t Look Down recently posted..Illinois Marathon Training Recap Week 5My Profile

  10. Last year was my first time winter running. I don’t belong to a gym or have access to a treadmill so all my runs were done outside. I know it wasn’t a super intense winter last year, but I loved running through the snow. 15 degrees sounds like a good cutoff though. When it is colder I try to run later in the morning or afternoon so it is not as cold.
    Cate recently posted..Five for FridayMy Profile

    • I love running in the snow too– I’d much rather run when it’s cold than when it’s hot! I’m glad you’re able to figure out a way to fit in runs when it’s cold without a gym :)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

CommentLuv badge